St. Luke’s Episcopal Church began demolition today of its original church building on the corner of Thirtieth and Gunn Streets. The additional space will significantly expand St. Luke’s participation in an innovative urban farming and culinary arts job training program for refugee women and youth run by the International Rescue Committee.
Begun in April, and launching in earnest this fall, the MAKE Garden Café project will transform St. Luke’s vacant lot into a productive and beautiful community space for at least the next three years. The Café will serve handcrafted teas, coffees, baked goods and salads prepared by refugee women employed in a job training program and operating out of St. Luke’s soon-to-be renovated commercial kitchen. Vegetables grown in the lot will be sold at the North Park Farmer’s Market and used in the catering programs’ products. The Garden Café will also feature a cultural arts gallery with rotating displays of sculptures, murals, woven arts and musical performances representing the many refugee and immigrant cultures in nearby City Heights.
“We look forward to the renewed and expanded use of St. Luke’s adjacent lot,” said Jim Stiven, president of the standing committee for the Episcopal Diocese of San Diego “As caretakers of ancient traditions, we understand the value of the historic fabric of our communities and the importance of process. We have worked closely with the North Park Historical Society and the Save Our Heritage Organization to consult the appropriate stakeholders in a thoroughly transparent and open process over the past several years.”
"The Diocese has been working closely with the historic preservation community, including the Save Our Heritage Organization (SOHO) for the past several years in trying to find an interested party willing to relocate the church building to another site,” said Scott Moomjian, historian and attorney who specializes in land use issues affecting historic properties. “Unfortunately, because the building was in such poor physical condition, and would cost hundreds of thousands of dollars to move and rehabilitate, no takers emerged."
“Our dream is to transform this property into a real blessing for the neighborhood,” said Joseph Jok, the board chair of St. Luke’s and a caseworker at the IRC. “I can’t wait to see where this new partnership with the IRC takes our congregation and the North Park community.” St. Luke’s is the spiritual home of about 50 families, many of whom are refugees from South Sudan.
Since 2013, the Episcopal Diocese of San Diego has actively sought interested parties to move the former church building to a different location, offering up to $7,500 to assist in moving costs. A number of individuals expressed interest, but after inspecting the structure, decided not to proceed.
The building was built sometime between 1887 and 1900. In 1924 it relocated from its original home at the corner of Sixth Avenue and Pennsylvania Street in Hillcrest where it served as the sanctuary of All Saints’ Episcopal Church. It measured 55’ x 32’ and consisted of 1,339 total square feet.
St. Luke’s Episcopal Church is a mission congregation in the Episcopal Diocese of San Diego (stlukesnorthpark.org). It is a multi-cultural congregation that welcomes everyone regardless of ethnic background, creed, age, physical capabilities, size or sexual orientation. All are welcome. The Episcopal Diocese of San Diego is a non-profit, religious organization comprised of 43 congregations in San Diego, Imperial and Riverside Counties, CA and Yuma County, AZ. The Episcopal Church welcomes all who worship Jesus Christ in 109 dioceses and three regional areas in 16 nations. The Episcopal Church is a member province of the worldwide Anglican Communion. For more information, please visit www.edsd.org.
St Luke’s Former Church Building Demolition Frequently Asked Questions
Q. What was the history of the church building and why couldn't it be saved?
A. After serving as the primary worship space for the St. Luke's community from 1924 until 1958, when the current church building was completed, the structure stayed in use as an interfaith thrift shop ministry for many years. However, over the subsequent decades its wooden structure became increasingly deteriorated to the point that a 2010 physical needs assessment asserted that the building could no longer be salvaged.
Q. Why is the building being demolished now?
A. The congregation of St. Luke’s would like to expand their services to the North Park community by using the space the building occupies to create a community garden. Music, art, a café, a job training program and more are being planned for this site. After years of working with the historic preservation community including the Save Our Heritage Organization (SOHO) to find an interested party willing to move the structure, the people of St. Luke’s have decided to move ahead with demolition.
Q. What was the historical significance of the church building?
A. Some have thought this structure was one of architect’s Irving Gill’s, but no evidence exists to support that claim. It was built between 1887 and 1900. In 1924 it was relocated from its original home at the corner of Sixth Avenue and Pennsylvania Street in Hillcrest where it served as the sanctuary of All Saints’ Episcopal Church.
Q. Why wasn't anything done to save the building?
A. The diocese looked for four years for a buyer to no avail. It also offered $7,500 to assist with moving costs but no one wanted to undertake that project.
One of the most problematic and disturbing passages in the Bible.